1891 Vancouver City Council Minutes

Mayor: David Oppenheimer Aldermen: Ward 1:  Sam Brighouse, J.T. Carroll Ward 2:  James F. Garden (resigned), Alexander Godfrey, A.W. Scouller (elected in byelection) Ward 3:  C.G. Hobson, William Templeton Ward 4:  William Brown, John McDowell Ward 4:  H. De Pencier (resigned), Charles Doering*, C.L. Brown (elected in byelection) information from Vancouver’s Elected Representatives by Wayne D. Madden, 2003 * Madden gives Charles Doering's surname as "Dooring"

Alderman James F. Garden resigns.  Hansen brothers of Montreal purchase $25,000 of city debentures. Crowder and Penzer granted contracts for coal and feed, provided that both be weighed on the Market scales. Miss Bowes requests stricter temperance regulations, also to “abolish houses of ill-fame” (brothels). Trades and Labour Council present request that no Chinese labour be allowed to be used on the graving dock contract. This transcript was made in 2017 by Transcribimus volunteer Anonymous and sponsored by Shirley Barnett original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 179 – 639 [Vol 4 pg 179] Vancouver Jan 12, 1891 The Council met on Monday January 12, 1891 at 8 P.M. Present His Worship Mayor Oppenheimer, Aldermen Brighouse, Carroll, Godfrey, Hobson, Templeton, Brown, McDowell, DePencier and Doering. The minutes of last meeting were read and adopted. Communications From Dr. Bodington claiming extra remuneration for going to Victoria as a Witness in the Case of the C.P.R. Co. vs the City. Finance From Messrs Eberts and Taylor and John Irving, President of the Vancouver Water Works Co. sending corrected agreement for the purchase of their Works. Co. Water Works Committee From Halley Bros & Granville Montreal requesting the City to subscribe towards Stereoptic Views of the city for the Jamaica Exhibition. Finance From Henry Laundry asking for a bonus of $1800 to assist him in starting a woollen mill. Finance From Messrs. Yates, Jay & Russell asking the City to drain the water of Lots 1.2.3. Block 32, Sub 541. Board of Works From W. L. Leonard protesting against the manner of awarding the contract for Rock Crusher. Board of Works From the City Solicitor informing the [Vol 4 pg 180] Council that he had tendered the President of the Improvement Co the purchase money for the Sugar Refinery Site and that he had refused to accept the amount offered $15,000 Finance From the Market Clerk furnishing the regular weekly reports of receipts. Filed From A. Gobeil, Secretary to the Department of Public Works acknowledging receipt of a Communication from the Mayor re Cambie Street Bridge. Filed From Wm Sidelman etal [sic] asking the Council to run out Powell Street in a direct line to the East Park. Board of Works. From A.J. Alcock etal [sic] asking for electric lights on Westminster Av at 10th & 13th avs and a sidewalk on the south side of 11th av from Quebec St to Westminster Road. F.W.L. & Board of Works. From James F. Garden tendering his resignation as Alderman. Filed. From the Chief of Police furnishing Report on Electric Lights. Filed. From G.A. Owens etal [sic] asking that the lane in Block 111.541 be opened for traffic Board of Works. From James McPhee asking for permission to run a wire on any street on any street or alley for the purpose of operating a Burglar Alarm System. Board of Works. [vol 4 page 181] From Miss. S. Bowes etal [sic] asking the Council to close Barrooms and Saloons

Tenders to be invited to supply the City with coal, wood, and feed for 1891, with the provision that coal and feed must be weighted at the Market scales before delivery. Residents of Mount Pleasant requested a police beat in their area, and a delegation also presented to Council their strong objection to the nuisance (odor) from Slaughter Houses nearby. The Health Department recommends that the old pest house (quarantine facility) "now wrecked on the shores of Dead Man's Island" be burned. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Anonymous and sponsored by Shirley Barnett original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 191 - 199 [Vol 4 pg 191] Vancouver January 19th 1891 The Council met on Monday January 18th 1891. Present His Worship Mayor Oppenheimer, Aldermen Brighouse, Carroll, Godfrey, Templeton, Brown, McDowell and DePencier. The Minutes of last meeting were read and adopted. Communications From Theodore Davie, Attorney General, acknowledging the receipt of a communications from the City Clerk re telephones in the Sheriff’s Office. Filed. From J. H. Carlisle and the members of the Fire Brigade asking for an increase of Salary. F.W. & L. Committee. From J. H. Carlisle drawing attention to the danger of the destruction of the Fire Alarm. F.W. & L Committee. From C. Lettey giving Statement of the expenses for Solicitors fees during 1890 Finance Mr. Walter H. Kendall offering to supply not less than #10,000 cubic yards of broken rock at $1.40 per cubic yard. Board of Works. From H. L. Freer & Co notifying Council that the insurance on the Library would expire on the 7th Feb, 1891 Finance From C. D. Rand, Secretary of the Improvement Co stating that unless the $15000, and 8 per cent interest for the Sugar Refining Site was paid before the 1st of February 1891 steps would be taken by the Company to declare the sale null and void. Finance [vol4 page 192] From S.J. Emanuels and A.H.B. McGowan enclosing resolutions passed by the Public Meeting at the Market Hall and Board of Trade respectively endorsing the graving dock By Law. Filed. From Courbould, McColl, Jenns and Campbell, notifying Council that unless their clients were settled that they would fence in their lots thereby closing Powell Street, through Block 48. Board of Works. From Jas. B. O Brian, Toronto, asking for a copy of the Mayor’s address. Filed. From V. W. Haywood, furnishing weekly report of lights. Filed. From the Market Clerk furnishing weekly report. Filed From G.A. Roedde giving explanations regarding his tender for book binding. Filed. From H. McGeer drawing attention to the improper location of streets in 264A. Board of Works. From the working men in the East Park claiming wages under the McDonald & Barton Contract. Board of Works. From R.A. McMorran etal [sic] asking for a sidewalk on 19th Av. Board of Works. From Wm Jones etal [sic] asking for a Policeman at Mount Pleasant. Police Committee. From the Coal Merchants of

Council agrees to acquire the Water Works from its current private owners. It was agreed to request the provincial government not to dissolve the current Small Debts Court Act until a judge is actually resident in Vancouver. Council to request the Dominion Government to establish a dry-dock in Vancouver large enough to accommodate ships to and from China, Japan, and Australia. This transcript was made in 2015 by Transcribimus volunteers Margaret Sutherland and Joy Marie Vasquez and sponsored by Arnold Silber   City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 3 pages 264-275 [volume 3 page 264] Vancouver January 27th 1890 The Council met on Monday January 27th 1890. Present His Worship, the Mayor and Aldermen Browning, Carroll, Horne, Garden, Fox, Sentell, Costello, McLeod, Mason and Doering. The Minutes of last meeting were read and adopted. Communications From Allan N. Stuart in reference to clay deposits for manufacturing pipes in Vancouver. Referred to the Board of Works. From Aveling & Porter in reference to rollers. Referred to the Board of Works. From E. B. Bristow & Co. in reference to the purchase of a Chemical Engine. Referred to the F. W. & L. Committee. From F. W. Hart requesting to be allowed to disinter A. L. McMullen’s remains. Referred to the Board of Health. From Dr. Robertson furnishing list of drugs required at Hospital. Referred to the Board of Health. From B. T. Rogers in reference to a Sugar refinery in Vancouver. Referred to the Finance Committee. From Royal Templars of Temperance praying that the Sale of Intoxicating Liquors be restricted etc. Referred to License Committee. [volume 3 page 265] From W. J. Gallagher et al praying that a Sewer in Block 41 District Lot 541 be completed. Referred to the Board of Works. From E. Mohun in reference to recording Sewer connections etc. Referred to the Board of Works. From the City Engineer reporting on the improvements of the North Arm Road. Referred to the Board of Works. From Miss Bowes furnishing copies of “Home Cheer”. Filed. From A. G. Hesslier and Wm. Dennis of Halifax sending the Vancouver Mayor and Council greetings on the completion of the Telegraphic Service to that point and reply of Mayor Oppenheimer. Filed. Reports F. W. & L. No 2 The Fire, Water & Light Committee met on Wednesday January 22nd 1890. Present Aldermen Fox, McLeod, Garden and Doering. We beg to recommend: 1. That the California Electrical Works be allowed to transfer its contract for the erection of the Electric Fire Alarm System to R. B. McMecking of Victoria. 2. That Alderman McLeod and Doering be allowed to test the team selected for the Fire Department and purchase it found satisfactory. Sgd. J. M. Fox, Chairman [volume 3 page 266] Moved by Alderman Costello, seconded by Alderman Doering. That the Report of the Fire, Water & Light Committee be adopted. Carried. Works No 2 The Board of Works met on Thursday January 23rd 1890. Present Aldermen Browning, Horne, Sentell and Doering. We beg

H. Abbott, General Superintendent of the C.P.R., denies C.P.R.’s responsibility to “furnish, at its own cost” the protection Council has requested at certain street crossings. The Board of Works orders that the City Morgue be connected to the water works and public sewers.  The lawyer for nearby resident Mr McMillan be contacted to see if his objection to the morgue “nuisance” can be settled amicably.  (Mr. McMillan was a grocer at the corner of Abbott and Water Street.) This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Christopher Stephenson and sponsored by Shirley Barnett original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 221-229 Vancouver Feb. 12th 1891. The Council met on Thursday February 12th 1891 at 8 P.M. Present His Worship the Mayor and Aldermen Brighouse, Carroll, Godfrey, Hobson, Templeton, Brown, McDowell, Doering and DePencier. The Minutes of last meeting were read and adopted. Communications. From J.C. Keith and E.E. Rand donating an oil portrait of Captain Vancouver to the City. Moved by Alderman Templeton Seconded by “ DePencier. That the gift be accepted and a vote of thanks tendered to the donors. Carried. From F.C. Cotton M.P.P acknowledging the receipt of a resolution from Council regarding appropriations for Hospitals, Museum and Fire Department. Filed. From E. Chanteloup offering to quote prices for a Market Clock. Referred to the Market Committee From Sam K. Champion asking to be favored with orders for material for the proposed Crematory. Referred to the Crematory Committee. From G.E. Corbould M.P. stating that he had received a communication from the Department of Public Works that the matter of the Construction of a Draw Bridge over False Creek is now before the Council. Filed. From Sentell and others praying for the improvement of Harris St. Referred to the Board of Works. From the Market Clerk furnishing his weekly report. Filed. From the City Auditor furnishing a statement of the receipts and disbursements for the month of January 1891. Filed. From J. Cooper Keith acknowledging receipt of letter re Sugar Refinery deposit, and stating that he had paid over the money as instructed. Filed. From Charles A. Beals et al praying for the improvement of Davie St. Referred to the Board of Works. From Messrs. Blake and Magee asking the City to pay L. Authier $75.00 being one month’s salary as Assistant Street Inspector. Referred to the Finance Committee From John Slade et al complaining about a nuisance on Gore Av. Referred to the Health Inspector. From H. Abbott, General Superintendent of the Canadian Pacific Railway Co. stating that he was not prepared to admit that the Company was liable to furnish at its own cost, the whole or any part of the protection which the Council desired should be provided at certain Street crossings. Referred to the Board of Works. From the Chief of Police furnishing a report on the Street lights for the fortnight ending February 7th 1891. Filed. From Bernard Hardy applying for a position on the Fire Brigade.

The Board of Works report instructs the City Clerk to fire the current Engineering Department staff and advertise for a new staff (Alderman Brighouse, Godfrey, Templeton and Brown supporting the motion, Alderman de Pencier dissenting). Mayor David Oppenheimer refuses to put the question to council, as he considered the action of the Board illegal in discharging the whole engineering staff. He left the room stating that any further business would be illegal. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Christopher Stephenson and sponsored by Shirley Barnett original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4, pages 235-245 Vancouver February 23rd 1891 The Council met on Monday February 23rd 1891 at 8 P.M. Present His Worship the Mayor, and Aldermen Brighouse, Carroll, Godfrey, Scoullar, Hobson, Templeton, Brown, McDowell, DePencier, and Doering. The Minutes of last meeting were read and adopted. Communications. From Dr. Thomas thanking the Council for appointing him to the position of hospital physician. Filed From the Chief of Police reporting upon the electric lights. Filed From the Police Magistrate reporting upon the case of John McCulloch. Referred to the Finance Committee From B.T. Rogers asking for the deeds of the Sugar Refinery Site. Referred to the Finance Committee From the City Solicitor furnishing a copy of the notice served on the Vancouver Water Works Co under Section 35 of their Act. Filed. From D. Robson, City Clerk of New Westminster acknowledging the receipt of the resolution of Council re the late fire. Filed From F.G. Twigg complaining about the Police Magistrate. Referred to the Police Committee From J.J. Blake asking for the British Columbia District Telegraph & Delivery Co asking for the use of the streets for their purposes Referred to the Board of Works. From the Market Clerk furnishing the weekly report. Filed From A.M. Tyson, Acting Adjutant Vancouver Rifles asking for the Market Hall for drilling purposes. Filed. From James Curran et al asking for a sidewalk on Homer Street from Nelson Street South. Referred to the Board of Works. From His Worship the Mayor informing the Council that Mr. J.M. Browning would consent to act as Arbitrator for the City in the Water Works purchase and recommending his appointment unanimously. Filed. From the Secretary of the School Board expressing disapproval of certain Sections of the proposed School Act and asking Council to endorse these objections Filed. The following reports were received and read:- Market. No 3. The Market Committee met on Friday February 20th 1891. Present Alderman Godfrey, Brown, Templeton, Brighouse and Doering A plan drawn by C.W.H. Sansom, showing the proposed changes to the Market Building to provide for a rear exit, was laid before the Committee for consideration. It was resolved that the plan be adopted with the exception that the stairway and doorway be made six feet wide instead of 4 ½ feet; it was further resolved that the specifications be prepared and tenders called for. The Committee fixed the 1st and 3rd Fridays in each month

Mayor and Aldermen Godfrey, Brown, Hobson, Scoullar, Carroll, McDowell, and Templeton to go to Victoria to meet the members of the Legislature with the view of having the proposed amendments to the Vancouver Water Works Co’s Act opposed This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Christopher Stephenson and sponsored by Shirley Barnett original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 page 247 only Vancouver Feb. 28th, 1891 A special meeting of the Council was held on Saturday February 28th 1891. Present His Worship the Mayor and Aldermen Carroll, Godfrey, Scoullar, Templeton, Hobson, Brown, McDowell and DePencier. The object of the meeting was to appoint a Committee to go to Victoria to oppose the proposed amendments to the Vancouver Water Works Co’s Charter. It was resolved, That His Worship the Mayor & Alderman Godfrey, Brown, Hobson, Scoullar, Carroll, McDowell, and Templeton with power to add to their numbers, be appointed to go to Victoria to meet the members of the Legislature with a view of having the proposed amendments to the Vancouver Water Works Co’s Act opposed. Carried. The Council then adjourned. D. Oppenheimer Mayor Thos. F. McGuigan City Clerk

A majority vote of two thirds of the aldermen present compelled Mayor Oppenheimer to sign the minutes of February 23, 24, 28 and March 9. Vancouver Trades and Labour council requested that the Chain Gang not be employed on Street Work. A bylaw to regulate the storage of inflammable material within the city limits was introduced and read a first time. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Christopher Stephenson, MLIS and sponsored by Shirley Barnett original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 250 – 264 Vancouver March 16th 1891 The Council met on Monday, March 16th 1891 Present His Worship the Mayor and Aldermen Brighouse, Scoullar, Godfrey, Templeton, Hobson, Brown, McDowell, DePencier, and Doering. The Minutes of last regular and special meetings were read. After the Minutes were read the Mayor stated that he still adhered to his decision not to sign the Minutes but that if a vote were taken on his ruling and if the necessary two-thirds majority decided against him it would be his duty to acquiesce. It was then moved by Alderman Templeton Seconded by Alderman Brighouse, That the Minutes of last regular and special meetings be adopted as read. Alderman Brown said that Alderman Godfrey joined with him in wishing the names of the Aldermen to be taken on the voting. Alderman Templeton then asked the Mayor if he refused to put the motion, the Mayor answered yes. The mover then put it to a vote of the Council and carried it on the following vote:- Yeas. Aldermen Brighouse, Scoullar, Godfrey, Templeton, Brown, and McDowell. Nays. Aldermen DePencier, Doering and Hobson. The Mayor stated that as he had been overruled he would now sign the Minutes. Alderman Carroll was absent when the vote was taken but arrived shortly afterwards Communications. From F. D. Boucher et al asking for a sidewalk on Thurlow Street. Referred to the Board of Works. From John McCulloch stating that the Police Magistrate made an order to have his clothes, papers etc left at the Customs House. Referred to the Police Committee. From A. Yorke asking the Council to look into the charges preferred against the Police Magistrate. Moved by Alderman DePencier Seconded by “ McDowell. That the communication be returned to the writer. Carried. From Robt. C. Buckeral submitting an affidavit preferring certain charges against the Police Magistrate. Referred to the Police Committee. From Joseph Pope and T. Trudeau acknowledging a communication from the City Clerk re fencing of streets at railway crossings. Filed. From J.A. Fulton, Secretary to the Trades and Labor Council asking that the Chain Gang be not employed on Street Work. Referred to the Board of Works. From Sinclair Harcus, applying for permission to move a frame building from Lot 3, Block 13, 196. to Block 29, 541 Referred to the Board of Works. From A. Tullis asking the Council to pay his salary as secretary to the Smelting Co out of the $5000.00 forfeited by the

Mayor Oppenheimer sends regrets and protest against “illegal” appointment of Thomas Tracy as City Engineer. Council to send letter of protest against the Attorney General’s reported intention to change several details of the City Charter. The meeting was adjourned out of respect to the memory of former Alderman Dr. James Whetham.   This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Donna Kynaston and sponsored by Shirley Barnett original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 266-268 Vancouver March 23rd 1891 The Council met on Monday March 23rd 1891. Present: Aldermen Brighouse, Carroll, Scoullar, Godfrey, Templeton, Brown, McDowell, DePencier and Doering. Moved by Alderman Doering Seconded by Alderman Godfrey That Alderman Brown be appointed Chairman. Carried. The minutes of last regular and special meetings were read and adopted on motion of Alderman Brighouse seconded by Alderman McDowell. Aldermen Carroll, dePencier and Doering did not vote. The following communication was read from the Mayor: Vancouver March 23rd 1891 To the Chairman & Aldermen, City Hall Gentlemen I exceedingly regret that I am unable to be present at the meeting of the Council this evening, as there are several important matters to which I should have desired to direct your attention. I beg to record my formal protest against the illegal appointment of Mr Tracey to the position of Chief Engineer of this City on the grounds that the Council has not acted in conformity with the City Charter and even had the proceedings of Friday last been legal and in accordance with the Vancouver Incorporation Act, the application on behalf of Mr Tracey ought not to have been received, as it was in every way irregular and not in accordance [Vol 4 page 267] with the advertisement calling for applications. I have the honor to remain Yours faithfully (sgd) D. Oppenheimer Mayor Motions Moved by Alderman Scoullar Seconded by Alderman Doering That the following labor accounts be paid: B. Romang et al $52.75 Carried. Moved by Alderman Brown Seconded by Alderman Templeton Whereas it appears by a reported statement made in the Legislature by the Attorney General that he will move amendments to those clauses in the City Charter reducing the qualifications of Mayor and Aldermen, taxing churches and regulating the butchering business. Be it resolved that inasmuch as these are matters of a purely local character affecting the citizens only, and as no petition or complaint of any kind has been presented to the Council in respect to the proposed changes this Council in the name of and on behalf of the citizens of Vancouver respectfully protests against any amendments and trusts that the members of the Legislature will cordially support the changes asked for. And further that a copy of this resolution be forwarded to the City Representatives. Carried. Moved by Alderman Godfrey Seconded by Alderman Templeton That out of respect to the [Vol 4 page 268] memory of Dr. James Whetham who formerly acted as an Alderman at the Council Board this Council

The anticipated arrival of the S.S. Empress of India from the Orient to be celebrated with a performance by the City Band and an address to the officers and passengers. Mayor David Oppenheimer absent. The Board of Works to have plans prepared for a Women’s and Children’s Hospital and sent to the City Clerk’s office by April 25th. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Martha Hazevoet and sponsored by Arnold Silber original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 284 - 290 Vancouver, April 6, 1891 The Council met on Monday, April 6, 1891. Present: Aldermen Brighouse, Carroll, Scoullar, Godfrey, Templeton, Hobson, Brown, McDowell and Doering. Moved by Alderman Templeton Seconded by Alderman Hobson That Alderman Scoullar be appointed Chairman. Carried The following communications were received and read: From Wm. Webster, Manager of the Union S.S. Co., giving the notice required by the Council as to dumping on the Wharf, and asking to be indemnified from expenses caused by any action from the Health Inspector. Referred to Health Committee From J.M. Browning asking whether it was the intention of the City to execute the lease of the Recreation Grounds. Referred to Finance Committee From John D. Ronald, asking the City to purchase another steam engine. Referred to F.W. & L. Committee From F.W. Mills et al asking that 7th Avenue from Quebec to Ontario Street be cleared and graded. Referred to the Board of Works From W.P. West giving ground report and asking for some rough lumber. Referred to Police Committee From the Market Clerk furnishing his usual weekly report. Filed From the Chief of Police furnishing his weekly report on the street lights. Filed From the City Solicitor asking that the slaughter house cases be withdrawn and requesting that he be consulted before law suits are go on with. [sic] Referred to Finance and Health From Drake, Jackson & Co., asking that 7th Avenue be graded from Centre Street to the site of the proposed hospital. Filed From R.H. Alexander et al asking that the petition for an investigation into the Engineering Department be considered. Moved by Alderman Brown Seconded by Alderman Brighouse That the communication be filed. Carried From his Worship the Mayor, asking that the arrival of the s.s. Empress of India be celebrated in a fitting manner. Filed From the press reporters asking for more light at the table. Referred to F.W. & L. Committee From H.S. Gilmour et al asking that Nelson Street be improved from Granville to Bute Street. Referred to the Board of Works The following reports were received and read: Market No. 5 The Market Committee met on Friday, April 3rd, 1891. Present: Aldermen Godfrey, Templeton, Brown and Brighouse. It was recommended: 1.  That the time for receiving tenders on the Market Hall exit be extended to Friday, April 17, 1891 at noon. 2.  That the Chairman be instructed to ascertain what it will cost to light the basement of the Market and to

In consideration of $2,000 grant given to the women’s and children’s hospital by the City, the Chairman of the Board of Health to be one of directors of the hospital. Ongoing conflict over the firing of Chief Engineer Warren and the hiring of Mr. Tracy. Five aldermen to review the composition of the city wards in terms of populations, budgets, and taxes received. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Christopher Stephenson and sponsored by Arnold Silber original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 297 - 309 Vancouver April 20th 1891. The Council met on Monday April 20th 1891. Present His Worship the Mayor and Aldermen Carroll, Brighouse, Godfrey, Scoullar, Templeton, Hobson, Brown, McDowell, Doering, and DePencier. The Minutes of last meeting were read and adopted. The following communications were received:- From the Market Clerk furnishing his weekly report. Filed. From Dr. Herbert applying for a position on the Medical Board of the City Hospital. Referred to the Health Committee. From M. Gibson asking for two trees to be cut down on 11th Av. Between Sofy [sic. Sophia] St. and Westminster Avenue. Referred to the Board of Works. From Edward C. Heastie asking for a settlement of the claims for wages on the South Park. Referred to the Board of Works. From Wm. Seidelman asking the Council to compel certain clearing to be done in 184. Referred to the Board of Works. From the City Solicitor stating that the necessary bonds were furnished in the Slaughter house appeal cases. Copy of letter to be sent to Wm. Towler. From Henry Collins etal [sic] asking that the lane between Richards & Homer Streets in Block 65.541 be graded. Referred to the Board of Works. From F.C. Rankin, Secretary of the Lacrosse Club, asking the Council to put the steam roller on the Brockton Point Lacrosse grounds; they defraying all expenses connected therewith. Filed. From J.S. O’Dwyer applying for the position of the City Engineer. Laid on the tables. From the Chief of Police furnishing his weekly report on the Street lights. Filed. From A.J. Dana etal [sic] asking for the gravelling etc of Robson Street. Referred to the Board of Works. From T.C. Booth etal [sic] asking for a sidewalk on the West side of Seymour Street. Referred to the Board of Works. From Thos. H. Tracy of London, Ont stating that on account of the Mayors protest and actions I think it not safe to throw up present position. Filed. From His Worship the Mayor denying that he was responsible for the non-acceptance of the position of City Engineer by Thos. Tracy and furnishing copies of his correspondence with him. Filed. The following Reports were received and read:- License No 3. Your Committee met for the transaction of business on Wednesday April 15th 1891 at 11:30 a.m. Present His Worship the Mayor and Aldermen McDowell, Hobson and Godfrey. His Worship in the Chair. Applications were received and read from Messrs Reid and

Appointment of Browning finalized. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Christopher Stephenson and sponsored by Arnold Silber original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 313 only Vancouver Apr 29/91 A Special meeting of the Council was held on Wednesday April 29th 1891 Present His Worship the Mayor, Aldermen Brown, Hobson, Godfrey, Carroll, Templeton, DePencier, and Scoullar. Moved by Alderman Carroll Seconder “ DePencier In pursuance of the provisions contained in Clause 2 of the Vancouver Water Works Act 1886 Amendment Act 1891 It is hereby resolved that Mr. J.M. Browning of Vancouver, Land Commissioner C.P.Ry Co. be and he is hereby appointed Arbitrator on behalf of the City of Vancouver in the matter of the Arbitration to be held as directed and provided for by the said Act. And notice under the Corporate Seal of such appointment be served on the Vancouver Water Works Co. The remuneration of Mr. Browning to be fixed at the same amount as the Vancouver Water Works Co. pay to their arbitrator, and that notice of his appointment be given to Mr. Browning The meeting then adjourned D. Oppenheimer Mayor Thos. F. McGuigan City Clerk

A Special Meeting was held to consider the Works By-Law; the by-law was read over, signed, sealed, and sent to the newspapers for publication This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Donna Kynaston and sponsored by Arnold Silber original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 page 323 only [volume 4 page 323] Vancouver May 9 1891 A special meeting of the Council was held on Saturday May 9th 1891 at 2 P.M. for the purpose of considering and finally passing the Works By-Law. Present: His Worship the Mayor and Aldermen Brighouse, Scoullar, Godfrey, Templeton, Brown, McDowell and Doering. The By-Law was read a second time on motion of Alderman Brown seconded by Alderman Brighouse. The Council went into Committee of the Whole on motion of Alderman Templeton seconded by Alderman Godfrey. Alderman Brown was appointed Chairman. The By-Law was read over clause by clause and reported back to Council as complete with amendments. The By-Law was then read a third time on motion of Alderman Brown seconded by Alderman Brighouse and ordered to be signed, sealed and gazetted. The Council then adjourned. D. Oppenheimer Mayor Thos. F. McGuigan City Clerk  

The Board of Works reported that “the South Park (now Clark Park on Commercial Drive between 14th and 15th Avenues) is to be seeded at once”, and that Robson Street cannot “at present” to be made to open onto “the Park” (Stanley Park). The continuing disagreement about the hiring of Mr. Tracy as Chief Engineer was set aside for one week. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Chris Mizzoni and sponsored by Arnold Silber original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 page 324 - 330 [volume 4 page 324] Vancouver May 11th 1891 The Council met on Monday May 11th 1891 at 8 P.M. Present His Worship, the Mayor and Aldermen Brighouse, Carroll, Scoullar, Godfrey, Brown, McDowell, Templeton, Hobson, Doering and DePencier. The Minutes of last regular and special meetings were read and adopted. The following communications were received and read: From William Wood etal [sic] requesting that 8th Av be graded from Prince Edward St. east four blocks. Referred to the Board of Works. From H.W. Keith informing Council that the Telephone Co. would allow a reduction of $1.00 on the City’s Telephone account except for the Instrument at the Cemetery. Referred to the Finance Committee From J.M. Browning asking that 4th & 6th Avs from Centre Street to Cedar Street be graded. Referred to Board of Works. From Samuel H. Longley of Boston offering to write up the features of this section of the Country. Referred to Finance Committee From Geo Eldon asking for the grading of Alberni Street. Referred to the Board of Works. From Wm. MacDonald asking the Council to remove rubbish deposited on his Lot on Hastings Street East. Referred to the Board of Works [volume 4 page 325] From G.W. Thomas stating that the Market Scales had been tested and found correct in every particular. Filed From the Market Clerk furnishing his Weekly Report. Filed From W. P. West asking for an increase of Salary. Referred to the Police Committee. From John Devine asking for the improvement of Princess Street from Carl Av east. Referred to the Board of Works. From Chas. Hay et al requesting Council to grade and sidewalk Thurlow St from Haro Street to Beach Av. Referred to the Board of Works. From the Chief of Police furnishing his weekly report on the street lights. Filed From A.J. Ryan drawing the attention of the Council to the remarks made by the Supreme Court Judges on the Judgements of the Police Magistrate. Referred to the Police Committee. The following reports were received and read: Finance No. 13. The Finance Committee met on Friday May 8th 1891. Present, Aldermen Brown, Doering and Scoullar. The Minutes of the last meeting were read and adopted. [volume 4 page 326] Moved by Alderman Scoullar That the bill of the World Printing and Publishing Co for advertising re City Engineer and Staff be not paid. Carried Moved by Alderman Scoullar That the bill of H. W. Suckling for engrossing

Alderman Brighouse refused to sign document of resignation previously signed by Mayor and all Aldermen, in response to demand brought forth at a recent public meeting. H. B. Warren brought suit against the City for wrongful dismissal. Aldermen Carroll and De Pencier made two unsuccessful motions to have the six Aldermen “whose action formed the basis for such lawsuit” the defendents, rather than the Council as a whole. Both motions defeated. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Leah Minuk and sponsored by Arnold Silber original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 page 343 - 352 [volume 4 page 343] Vancouver May 26th 1891 The City Council met on Tuesday, May 26th 1891 at 8 P.M. Present His Worship the Mayor and Aldermen Brighouse, Carroll, Godfrey, Scoullar, Hobson, Templeton, Brown and McDowell & De Pencier. The minutes of the last meeting were read and adopted. The following communications were received and read: From the City Solicitor in reference to the deeding of the Sugar Refinery Site. Referred to the Finance Committee From G. E. Corbould M.P. stating that he had not received the telegram from the City Clerk re attending the Privy Council meeting until too late. Filed From J. Wilson Supt. C.P. Tel Co. stating that all poles taken down had been removed. Referred to the Board of Works From W.J.M. Browning drawing attention to the recommendations of the Board of Works re streets on Fairview. Referred to the Board of Works. From the Market Clerk furnishing his week by report. Filed From John T. Williams et al petitioning for the removal of the fire limits from part of Block 53.541. Referred to F.W&H. Committee From Dr. Herbert thanking the Council for appointing him to the position of Hospital Dr. Filed From R.K. Winters informing the Council that the Police Magistrate was no longer qualified to act. Referred to the Police Committee From E.T. Bodwell giving notice of a suit being entered against the City by H. B. Warren. Filed [volume 4 page 344] From Alexander S. Potts Secretary of a public meeting submitting a resolution asking the Mayor and Aldermen to resign. Filed From A.J. Ryan giving a description of himself. Filed From G.W. Thomas submitting his weekly report on Market receipts Filed From J. W. McFarland stating that his account for extra flushing should be paid. Referred to the F.W. & H. Committee From J. W. McFarland asking for particulars as to special jury fees said to be due to the City by the Water Works Co. Referred to Finance Committee From City Solicitor stating that the Council had the power to control the erection of telephone poles on the streets. Referred to the Board of Works From the Chief of Police reporting upon the street lights filed. Filed From the Department of Agriculture giving the Council permission to erect a swing bridge over False Creek. Filed From Sam A. Brown on behalf of the Zion Church asking for a

Dr. A. C. Smith reported that “after full investigation, there were no signs of leprosy within the City”. Meanwhile, hospital matron Miss Swan was directed to “exclude all cases of venereal disease from the Hospital”. Mr. Tracy's appointment as City Engineer was finally confirmed. The Finance Committee provided detailed summaries of expenditures for all city departments: firemen paid $667 per year, policemen $840, nurses $345 This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Martha Hazevoet and sponsored by Arnold Silber original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 page 356 - 371 Volume 4, pg. 356 Vancouver, June 1, 1891 The Council met on Monday, June 1, 1891. Present: His Worship the Mayor and Aldermen Carroll, Brighouse, Scoular, Godfrey, Templeton, Hobson, McDowell, Doering and De Pencier. The minutes of last meeting were read and adopted. The following communications were received and read: From John McConaghy et al asking to be supplied with water in the east end of the City. Referred to the F.W. & L. Committee From A.H.D. MacGowan, Secretary to the Celebration Committee, asking to be made clear regarding the Council’s grant of $1000.00. Filed From R.T. Williams stating that he would publish a description of the City from the manuscript prepared by the Board of Trade. Referred to Finance Committee From R.H. Alexander declining to accept the office of Police Magistrate. Referred to the Police Committee From W.P. West furnishing his report on the Pound for the month of May. Filed From G.W. Thomas furnishing his weekly Market report. Filed From the Dominion Sanitary and Cremation Co. asking when the City intended going on with the erection of the Crematory. Referred to Crematory Committee Vol. 4, pg. 357 From R.V. Palmer asking that the sanitary condition of Dupont Street be improved. Referred to the Health Committee From George L. Morency asking for a position on the Fire Brigade. Referred to the F.W. & L. Committee From the City Solicitor giving a legal opinion as to the appointment of Mr. Lawson. Filed From Wm. Webster offering to build a scow with a false bottom for the sum of $1200.00. Referred to the Health Committee From Archibald Robinson et al asking that Raymur Avenue and Keefer Street be opened up. Referred to Board of Works From the Chief of Police furnishing an account of the street lights. Filed From John P. Hale et al asking that the Fire Limit By-Law be amended to fix the boundary at Columbia Avenue. Referred to the F.W. & L. Committee From G.W. Thomas asking that the Council take into consideration the reduction of the hours for the Market gardeners to be on the market. Referred to Market Committee From Mark Little et al praying for the grading of Pacific Street. Referred to the Board or Works From the Reporters asking for drawers in the table and easy chairs. Referred to Finance Committee Vol. 4, pg. 358 From the City Solicitor stating that it would be necessary to apply

The Board of Licenses approved liquor licenses for 47 hotels, 8 saloons, 6 retail establishments (including the Hudson's Bay Company) and 6 wholesalers. City taxes were raised to 2% "to provide an additional sum for school purposes". This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Linda Evans and sponsored by Arnold Silber original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 373 - 387 [Volume 4, pg. 373] Vancouver June 15th 1891 The Council met on Monday, June 15, 1891 at 8 p.m. Present His Worship the Mayor and Aldermen Carroll, Brighouse, Godfrey, Scoullar, Templeton, Hobson, Brown, McDonnell and Doering. The Minutes of the last meeting were read and adopted. The following communications were received and read;- From D. Oppenheimer President of the Provincial Exhibit Association of B.C., asking the Council to grant $50000 towards assisting in furnishing an exhibit. Referred to the Finance Committee From John Maxwell, Reeve of Langley, sending congratulations on the opening of telegraphic communications between Langley and this City; and the Mayor’s reply thereto. Filed From. H.W. Kurt, Manager of the Telephone Co. asking to have a box drain removed from the line of their poles. Referred to the Board of Works From. Thos. H. Tracy of London stating that he was sick in bed and did not know when he would be able to start. Filed From Alderman Carroll and the City Solicitor recommending that Mr. McMillan be paid $25000 and the taxed costs for damages sustained through the positioning of the Morgue near his property. Filed From the Hon. Hugh Wilson acknowledging the receipt of the resolution of Council re the appointment of Mr Hallett as J.P. Filed [Volume 4 page 374] From Mr. Abbott, in reference to the drainage of Richards and Seymour Streets. Referred to the Board of Works From Wm Crickmay asking for the balance of his account for pulleys etc. Referred to the Board of Works From the Chief of Police reporting upon the Street Lights – Filed From W. P. Parsons asking for a position as Sewer Inspector. Referred to the Board of Works From P. P. Clarke asking for the position of City Engineer. Filed From Joseph Pope acknowledging the receipt of the telegram of condolence to Lady Macdonald. Filed From Geo. A. Black et al on behalf of the people of Fairhaven inviting the Mayor and Council of Vancouver to be present in their City on the 4th of July. Filed From the City Solicitor furnishing by-laws for submission to Council. Filed From James Morrison complaining about the condition of Water Street on the North Side. Referred to the Board of Works. From Miss Swan stating that she would be obliged to discharge Miss Drummond. Health. [Volume 4 page 375] From A. Campbell Reddie Deputy Provincial Secretary, asking to be furnished with certain information in reference to the Police Magistrate. Filed The following Reports were received and read;- License To the Mayor and Aldermen of the City of Vancouver. Your Committee

Firemens' salaries were raised to $10 per month ($25 for Fire Chief J. H. Carlisle). Nurses' salaries were raised by $5 per month ($10 for matron Swan). Council chambers were ordered painted and repaired. Detailed regulations for sanitary storage and transportation of "the bodies of persons dying in this City" to be printed and distributed to each undertaker and practising physician. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Anonymous and sponsored by Arnold Silber original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 388 - 394 [Volume 4, pg. 395] Vancouver June 29 1891 The Council met on Monday, June 29th 1891 at 8 p.m. Present His Worship the Mayor and Aldermen Brighouse, Carroll, Godfrey, Scoullar, Templeton, Hobson, Brown, Doering & DePencier. The Minutes of the last meeting were read and adopted on motion of Alderman Scoullar Seconded by Alderman Hobson. The following communications were received and read:- From A. H. B. Macgowan, Secretary of the Board of Trade, calling attention that no Mortuary Statistics were published for Vancouver. Referred to Health Committee From McPhillips & Williams asking the City to pay over to them certain monies belonging to W. J. McMillan, against which they had a lien. Referred to the Finance Committee From. J. M. Darling et al of Fairhaven, and W. R. Forrest of Seattle inviting the Mayor & Council to their respective cities on the 4th of July. Filed From Thos H. Tracy stating that he would be here on Tuesday. Filed From W. L. Fagan stating that we would not accept the position of Poll Tax Collector. Filed From F. W. Hart stating that he would bury the pauper dead for $17.00 each. Referred to Health Com. From W. E. Brown, drawing attention to the danger [Volume 4 page 396] of children playing on Powell Street in front of the Street Cars. Referred to the Police Committee From the Market Clerk furnishing his weekly report. Filed From the City Clerk of New Westminster asking the Council for the loan of the Steam Road Roller. Filed From J. T. Williams etal petitioning for the removal of the Fire Limits from part of Block 53.541 Filed From the Chief of Police furnishing his weekly report on the Street Lights; Filed From Rand Bros. et al petitioning against the location of the crematory at the end of Gore Av. Referred to the Crematory Com. Mr. E. Odlum appeared before the Bar of the Council in support of the petition The following Reports were received and read:- Police No 14 The Police Committee met on Tuesday June 23rd 1891. Present Aldermen Hobson, Scoullar, Carroll Communications From Dr. Langis, asking for payment of his account for mental examination of Mrs. McMillan. Resolved that the accounts of both Dr Langis [Volume 4 page 397] and McGuigan for mental examination of Mrs McMillan be forwarded to Mr McMillan with a request that he will pay them. The list of charges made against Mr Hallet and the list

The school board were unanimously elected by Council ballot; Brown was elected Chairman. An offer to the New Westminster and Vancouver Tramway Company was drafted. The city would grade certain streets, then allow the company to put in its rails. The Company had 30 days to respond to the offer. E. Heywood appointed night constable at $100 per month. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Anonymous and sponsored by Shirley Barnett original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 408 – 312 [Volume 4, pg. 408] Vancouver July 6th 1891 The Council met on Monday, July 6th 1891 at 8 p.m. Present His Worship the Mayor and Aldermen Brighouse, Carroll, Godfrey, Scoullar, Templeton, Hobson, Brown, and Doering. The Minutes of the last meeting were read and adopted. The following Communications were received and read:- From Annie S. Kenrick applying for the position of Nurse in the City Hospital. Referred to the Board of Health From Albert Nye applying for the position of Poll Tax Collector. Referred to Finance Committee. From A Campbell Reddie, Deputy Provincial Secretary, acknowledging the receipt of the desired information regarding the Police Magistrate. Filed From R. C. Pitt asking for recompense for the loss of his foot. Referred to the Finance Committee From the Market Clerk furnishing his weekly report. Filed From the Chief of Police furnishing his weekly report on the street lights. Filed From the Pound Keeper furnishing his monthly report Filed [Volume 4 page 409] From Ernest Haywood asking to be sworn in as Special Constable in place of Malcolm McLean on leave of absence. Filed. From Miss Bowes asking for the removal of indecent pictures from certain cigar stores on Cordova Street. Referred to the Police Commissioner. From J. A. Fulton Secretary to the Trades and Labor Council drawing the attention of Council to a resolution passed regarding the New Westminster & Vancouver Tramway Co; also directing the attention of the Council to the violation of the Nine hours system. Filed. From Corbould, McColl, Wilson & Campbell insisting on behalf of the Vancouver Electric Railway, and Light Company to be allowed to exercise their option under Section 25 of the Street Railway Agreement; regarding the proposition of the Westminster & Vancouver Tramway Co. Filed. From R. P. Cooke etal protesting against the Tramway coming up Oppenheimer St. Filed From J. L. Brown et al asking for the grading of the lane in Block 16.196. Referred to the Board of Works. From the City Engineer recommending the temporary appointment of J. P. Lawson, A. K. Stuart, Thos Stephenson and John Brenton, on the Engineering Staff. Referred to the Board of Works. [Volume 4 page 410] The following Reports were received and read Finance No 20. The Finance Committee met on Friday July 3, 1891. Present Aldermen Brown, Scoullar, Hobson & Doering. Communications From J. W. Fonseca, asking for the position of Poll Tax Collector. Resolved that an advertisement be put in the newspaper calling for

Mrs. McDonald, wife of the cemetery keeper, to be paid $5.00 per month for attending to the telephone. City Solicitor gave his opinion that the position of Police Magistrate is technically vacant as Mr. Isaac Hallett is not a qualified Justice of the Peace. Hallett's position as a Stipendiary Magistrate allows him to collect fines under the City Bylaws. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Donna Kynaston and sponsored by Shirley Barnett original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 428 – 433 [vol 4 page 428] Vancouver July 20 1891 The Council met on Monday July 20th 1891 at 8 P.M. Present: His Worship the Mayor and Aldermen Brighouse, Carroll, Godfrey, Scoullar, Hobson, Templeton, Brown & McDowell. The minutes of last meeting were read and adopted. The following communications were received and read: From the Chief of Police reporting on the Street Lights. Filed. From the City Solicitor stating that E.J. Clark of Toronto ought to pay to the City the $1000.00 promised on the South Park. Referred to Finance Committee. From A. Campbell Reddie, Dep Prov Secretary acknowledging the receipt of the notification giving the names of the School Trustees appointed by the Council. Filed. From Henry A. Barton Dep Attorney General, asking to be informed whether Mr. Hallett’s appointment as Police Magistrate had been cancelled by resignation or otherwise. Referred to Police Committee. From G.W. Thomas, Market Clerk furnishing his weekly report. Filed. From the City Solicitor stating that the office of Police Magistrate was vacant through Mr. Hallett not being a J.P. and stating [vol 4 page 429] that he was empowered to try cases under the City By-Laws on account of him being a Stipendiary Magistrate be he [sic] has not under the regulations of the City. Referred to the Police Committee. From W.D. Burdis et al asking for a stand pipe for fire purposes at the junction of Campbell Av and Princess St. Referred to the Board of F W & L. From Wm Ralph et al asking that the Tramway come down Hastings St. Referred to the Board of Works. From David Brockwell asking that two trees be cut down on the corner of Lansdowne & Scotia Streets. Referred to City Engineer. From R.D. Pitt asking to be allowed to explain his case to the Council. The City Clerk was instructed to ask Mr. Pitt to be present. From Joseph Pope of Ottawa conveying the thanks of Lady Macdonald to the Mayor & Council of Vancouver for their kind sympathy with her in her affliction. Filed. From J.H. Smith complaining of the conduct of the Health Inspector. Referred to the Health Committee. The following accounts were received and read: Finance No 22 The Finance Committee met on Friday [vol 4 page 430] July 17th 1891. Present: Aldermen Brown, Hobson and Scoullar. It was recommended: 1. That the communication from R. D. Pitt asking for remuneration for the loss be referred back to Council for discussion.

Water Works arbitration panel Browning, Tilton and Drake submit their findings. The City to regulate private “scavengering” (garbage/recycling collection) within the city as soon as the waste-burning Crematory is in operation. Police officer Joseph Gibson dismissed for being found asleep on the job. J.W Robinson and J.M. Fox appointed as Tax Assessors, and H. Hemlow appointed to assist City Clerk McGuigan with the voters' list updates, all at a salary of $4.00 per day. The City Engineer to plan brick receiving vaults forthe Cemetery, and a new wing for the Hospital. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Martha Hazevoet and sponsored by Shirley Barnett original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 441 – 453 [ Vol. 4, pg. 441] Vancouver, August 3, 1891 The Council met on Monday, August 3rd, 1891. Present: His Worship the Mayor and Aldermen Carrall, Brighouse, Godfrey, Scoullar, Hobson, Templeton, Brown and McDowell. The minutes of last meeting were read and adopted. The following communications were received: From J.M. Browning, Land Commissioner, stating that he would extend the streets in District Lot 526 to the water front. Referred to the Board of Works From the City Solicitor stating that he had entered an appearance for the City in case of Studden vs the City. Filed From the Deputy Attorney General returning Writ of Summons in case of Mrs. Studden vs City. Filed From the City Solicitor stating that he was ready to receive advice from the various committees on the revision of the By-Laws. Referred to the By-Law Committee From Chipman Morgan & Co. on behalf of the Dry dock Company asking for a further extension of time. Referred to Board of Works From R.G. Tatlow on behalf of the Park Commissioners asking the Council for a grant of $500.00 for underbrushing on Brockton Point. Referred to Finance Committee From the Chief of Police reporting on the Electric Lights. Filed [Vol. 4 pg. 442] From McPhillips & Williams on behalf of the Vancouver Lightening Messenger Service Co. to string wires etc. on the streets. Referred to the Board of Works From Louisa Wilson asking for certain improvements in the Box drain on the corner of Westminster Avenue and Hastings Street. Referred to the Board of Works From J.A. Fulton, Secretary of Trades and Labour Council, asking for the enforcement of the nine hours system on City Contracts and for regulations regarding bathing on English Bay. Referred to the Board of Works From W.P. West, Pound Keeper, furnishing his monthly report. Filed From A.F. Beasley, Secretary Vancouver Gun Club, asking for permission to practice trap shooting within the city limits. Referred to the Police Committee From Miss Bowes furnishing programmes of the Provincial Convention. Filed From the Market Clerk furnishing his weekly report. Filed From P.G. Fenton et al asking for a sidewalk on Seymour Street. Referred to the Board of Works From Mrs. Studden asking to have her name withdrawn from the case of Studden vs the

The Police Chief authorized to prevent the New Westminster Tramway Co to interfere with Vancouver streets, and to obtain extra assistance if necessary. Alderman Carroll authorized to purchase an artificial leg for Mr. R. D. Pitt, “the City to pay for same.” By-Laws introduced to raise $440,000 “by way of debentures” for the purchase of the Vancouver Water Works and a further $150,000 for the extension of the Water Works. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Chris Stephenson, MLIS and sponsored by Shirley Barnett original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 456 – 451 Vancouver August 10, 1891. The Council met on Monday August 10th 1891 Present His Worship, the Mayor, and Aldermen Carroll, Godfrey, Scoullar, Templeton, Hobson, Brown, McDowell, and Doering. The Minutes of last meetings were read and adopted. The following communications were received and read:- From W.S. Salsbury giving amount due to the Vancouver Water Works Co. on account of interest: Same being $33,847.44 Filed From Chas. H. Tupper, Minister of Marine stating that the question of Foreshore rights were still under consideration Filed. From D. H. Morgan et al asking for a 3 ft on 13th Av. Referred to Board of Works From John Clark et al asking for the opening up of Manitoba Street, Referred to Board of Works. From the Secy of the School Board requesting that $2500.00 be placed to the credit of the Board Referred to Finance Committee From the Market Clerk furnishing weekly report. Filed From the Chief of Police on Electric lights. Filed From the City Solicitor stating that it was illegal for the Tramway Co and the Electric Light Co to break up the streets. Referred to the Board of Works. From C. N. Davidson et al, asking that Robson Street be graded and that the street cars be allowed to run over same. Referred to Board of Works. From J.J. Nickson [sp. should be Nixon] Supt. of Water Works giving the amount of money that would be required for extending the Water Works system. Filed. The following reports were received and read Finance The Finance Committee met on Friday August 7, 1891. Present Aldermen Brown, Scoullar, Hobson, and Carroll. It was recommended:- 1. That the following accounts be paid:- C.P. Telegraph Co. $3.85 H. McDowell & Co. drugs. 3.20 Telephone Co. 23.10 2. That the City Solicitor be instructed to enter an appearance for the City in the suit of Carbould & McColl vs the City; who are suing to recover $100.00 costs in the Schmidt case. 3. That the Park Commissioner be informed that the City has no funds at present to grant to them for underbrushing Brockton Point. 4. That the time be extended until the 1st of September for allowing the 20 percent rebate on taxes. 5. That instructions be given to Aldermen Carroll to purchase artificial leg for Mr. R.D. Pitt the City to pay for same. 6. That the valuators be instructed to assess

Officer Grady "allowed $12 for a suit of clothes." R.W. Hart awarded the contract for "burying the pauper dead at the rate of $15 for each corpse. " The City Council "will not countenance any monopoly of the bathing facilities on [English] Bay”. Bylaw "granting the New Westminster Tramway Co. power to construct and operate a tramway line over certain streets in Vancouver." This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Donna Kynaston and sponsored by Shirley Barnett original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 463-472 [Vol 4 page 463] Vancouver August 17th 1891 The Council met on Monday August 17th 1891. Present: His Worship the Mayor and Aldermen Carroll, Godfrey, Scoullar, Hobson, Templeton, Brown, McDowell and Doering. The minutes of last regular and special meetings were read and adopted. The following communications were received and read: From Mrs. E.C. Caldwell asking for a sidewalk on Harris St and the grading of the lane in Block 87, 196. Referred to the Board of Works. From McPhillips & Williams protesting against the erection of the crematory on Lots 7 & 8, Block 3, 302. Referred to the Board of Works. From H.B. Warren asking for his hotel and travelling expenses during the time he attended the Water Works arbitration. Referred to Finance Committee. From Alex Struthers et al asking for the opening of the lane in Block 6, 185. Referred to the Board of Works. From Eberts and Taylor, Solicitors for the Vancouver Water Works Co submitting an account for hydrant rent and the lowering of their pipes. Referred to F. W. & L. Committee. From the Crematory Co asking for an advance of $1600 on material furnished. Referred to Crematory Committee with power to act. From the Market Clerk furnishing a report. Filed. [Vol 4 page 464] From the Chief of Police requesting that his office and the waiting room be painted. Filed. From W.H. May et al asking for a sidewalk on Lansdowne St. Referred to the Board of Works. From Springer Mellon & Co asking for a share of City Insurance. Referred to Finance Committee. From Malcolm Smith, notifying the Aldermen that unless they refunded the amount paid out in the Hayes & McIntosh case, he would bring an action against each of them individually. Referred to the Finance Committee. From W.H. Copp et al and R.A. Anderson et al asking for a sidewalk on Park Drive and Venables Street. Referred to the Board of Works. From W.A. Taylor asking the City to refund $35.00 paid by the Orange Lodge during the visit of Mr. Johnson, for the rent of the Market Hall. Referred to the Market Committee. From the Chief of Police furnishing his weekly report on street lights. Filed. The following reports were received and considered. Police The Police Committee met on Tuesday August 11th, 1891. Present: Aldermen McDowell, Carroll, Hobson & Scoullar. Alderman McDowell in the Chair. [Vol 4 page 465] It was recommended: 1. That the City

Federal government seems to have stopped building post office on Granville Street, but has left stone blocks and building debris obstructing traffic. Two railcar loads of gravel to be purchased from the CPR for use on city streets. A by-election to be held, as Alderman de Pencier has left the city. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Martha Hazevoet and sponsored by Shirley Barnett original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 487-494 Vol. 4, pg. 487 Vancouver, September 7, 1891 The Council met on Monday, September 7, 1891. Present: Aldermen Carrall, Brighouse, Godfrey, Templeton, Hobson, Brown and McDowell. Alderman Brighouse was appointed Chairman. The minutes of last meeting were read and adopted. The following communications were received and read: From H. Stanton, Private Secretary to the Lieutenant Governor acknowledging the receipt of a communication re Mr. Hallett. Filed From Springer & Campbell offering to write up the City on condition that the Council would subscribe for a certain number of copies of the issue containing such descriptions. Filed From J.C. Drewry on behalf of the Toronto Globe offering a similar proposition for the consideration of Council. Filed From Thos. H. Robson et al praying for the sidewalking of Keefer Street. Referred to Board of Works From the Secretary of the Board of Trade inviting the Council to take seats on the platform in the Market Hall on the 8th inst. during the lecture of Colonel Howard Vincent. Filed From Henry A. Barton, Deputy Attorney General, informing Council that it was contemplated to hold an enquiry on the complaint against Mr. Hallett. From the Chief of Police reporting on the Electric Street Lights. Filed Vol. 4, pg. 488 From E. Chapman et al asking for the grading of 7th Avenue from Centre Street to Hemlock Street. Referred to Board of Works From the Market Clerk furnishing weekly report. Filed From Malcolm Smith stating that it would be unnecessary to hold an investigation on the complaints against Mr. Hallett as the Government intended to do so. Referred to Police Committee From J.A. Fulton asking that the streets be sprinkled along the line of the march on Labour Day. Referred to Board of Works From C.S. Douglas asking for a sidewalk on Burrard Street between Melville and Eveleigh. Referred to Board of Works From John Matthews et al requesting that the land in rear of Eveleigh Street be graded. Referred to Board of Works From H. Abbott asking that the crushed rock be delivered on scows at the C.P.R. slip. Referred to Board of Works with power to act From Yates, Jay & Russell asking for a settlement of the claim of J.G. McDonald on Westminster Avenue. Referred to Board of Works From T.T. Black et al asking that the Fire Limits be extended to embrace the whole of Granville Street. Referred to F.W. & L. Committee Vol. 4, pg. 489 The following reports were received and considered: Finance The Finance Committee met on

Council “cordially endorses” Victoria council’s plan for a BC building at the (1893) Chicago World’s Fair. The Board of Health met to discuss the care and treatment of two Chinese lepers formerly employed by the CPR. Advertisement for a new Police Magistrate postponed for 3 months. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Martha Hazevoet and sponsored by Shirley Barnett original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 504-513 Vol. 4, pg. 504 Vancouver, September 28, 1891 The Council met on Monday, September 28, 1891. Present: His Worship the Mayor and Aldermen Carrall, Scoullar, Templeton, Hobson, Brown, McDowell and Doering. The Minutes of last meeting were read and adopted. The following communications were received and read: From the Post Master General acknowledging the receipt of the communication re the obstructions on Granville Street. Filed From the Market Clerk furnishing his weekly report. Filed From the Chief of Police furnishing report on the street lights. Filed From Wm. Fowler asking what action had been taken regarding the Slaughter Houses. Referred to Board of Health From the Provincial Secretary stating that he would furnish a list of those who had paid their poll tax. Referred to Finance Committee From C.E. Renouf, Secretary of the B.C. Agricultural Exhibition, Victoria, inviting the Mayor and Aldermen to be present on the 30th inst. Filed From R. Mills et al asking for the clear-…. Vol. 4, pg. 505 … -ing of a certain portion of 9th Avenue near Block 27. Referred to Board of Works From D.G. McDonald et al asking for the grading of Front Street. Referred to Board of Works From W.C. Weir, Baptist Preacher, recommending the appointment of Robert S. Caldwell as Police Officer. Referred to Police Committee From John Kinghorn, Kingston, Secretary to the Sir John McDonald National Memorial Association, enclosing subscription books etc. Laid over From M. Metcalfe et al asking for the grading of 14th Avenue from Westminster Avenue to Quebec Street. Referred to Board of Works From the City Clerk of Victoria forwarding a copy of a resolution passed by the Victoria Council endorsing a project of the Immigration Investment and Improvement Co. Ltd. for the erection of a building at the World Fair Chicago, made of British Columbia wood etc. Moved by Alderman Brown Seconded by Alderman Templeton That the communication received through the City Council of Victoria to have erected at the Chicago Fair a building made of British Columbia Woods surrounded by native shrubs be cordially endorsed. Carried Vol. 4, pg. 506 The following reports were received and read: Police The Police Committee met on Tuesday, September 22nd, 1891. Present: Aldermen Hobson, McDowell, Carrall and Scoullar. It was recommended: 1) That the following accounts be paid: John Sciutto, supplies $ 36.78 Gurney Cab Co. 4.75 2) That tenders be again invited for furnishing police uniforms, only one tender having been received. The following applications were received for the position of Police Officer: John O. Flynn, J.J. Carment, M. McLean,

Isaac Hallett resigned as Police Magistrate and was paid out at $125.00 per month. The lane in Block 97 D.L. 196 be graded by the chain gang. James Carnahan allowed to cut wood from five acres of the Cemetery Grounds at 20 cents a cord. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Jordan Cripps and sponsored by Shirley Barnett original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 519-523 Vol. 4, pg. 519 October 12, 1891 The Council met on Monday October 12, 1891 Present: His Worship the mayor and aldermen Brighouse, Carrall, Godfrey, Scoullar, Hobson, Templeton, Brown - Wm & C.L., & McDowell The minutes of last meeting were read and adopted. The following communications were received and read. From H.G. Lewis Dept of Marine Victoria in reference to moving back the road in the vicinity of the Bell Tower at Brockton. Referred to Board of Works From the Department of Marine stating that Legislation would be required before the names of the “First Narrows” and “False Creek” could be changed. Referred to Alderman Godfrey From the City Clerk of Victoria acknowledging the receipt of the resolution of Council re: the construction of a B.C. Building at the World’s Fair Chicago. Filed From J.H. McMillan offering to sell his lots in rear of the Hospital for $5100.00. Referred to Health Committee. From the Deputy Attorney notifying the Council of the suspension of I.H. Hallett as Stipendiary Magistrate. Referred to Police Committee. From Ed Chapman et al. asking for the grading of 7th as one block east of Centre Street. Referred to Board of Works. The following communication was ordered to be spread on the minutes on motion of Alderman Templeton seconded by Alderman Scoullar: Vancouver, B.C 18th Oct – 1891 The Treasurer of City of Vancouver Dear Sir. We beg to hand you herewith 45 cancelled Water Street Local Improvement debentures of $100.00 each payable 1st October 1891 together with the paid coupons of the years 1888, 1889, 1890, & 1891. This retires the loan of $4500 issued under By-Law no. 9. Kindly acknowledge receipt. The Trustees of the Sinking Funds funds ask you to kindly have the fact of the payment of this loan recorded on the minutes of this council Yours Faithfully Sgd J.C. Keith - Trustees of Sinking fund R.G. Tatlow From the Market Clerk furnishing weekly report. Filed From the Pound Keeper asking for repairs to the Pound House. Referred to Police Committee From the City Solicitor, asking if the City would bear their proportion of the expenses of removing the squatters off the foreshore. Referred to Board of Works From the World & Telegram asking for an investigation into the manner in which the city advertising is being done. Referred to Finance Committee From the City Solicitor, stating that the City was liable for the management of the hydrant rental. Referred to the F.W. & L. Committee From I. W. Haywood, Sergeant of Police reporting on the Street

Recent city census taken by Mackay and Emanuels shows population to be 18,260. Finance committee enquired into the City’s advertising in the News-Advertiser, and concluded that there was no over-charging by the newspaper. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Donna Kynaston and sponsored by Shirley Barnett original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 535-542 [Vol 4 page 535] Vancouver October 26th 1891 The Council met on Monday October 26th 1891. Present: Aldermen Brighouse, Carroll, Godfrey, Scoullar, Hobson, Templeton, Wm Brown, McDowell and C.L. Brown. Moved by Alderman Templeton Seconded by Alderman C.L. Brown That Alderman Hobson be appointed Chairman. Carried. The minutes of last meeting were read and adopted. The following communications were received and read: From George Campbell et al asking for an electric light on the corner of Prior Street and Dunlevy Av. Referred to F. W. & L. Committee. From W.J. Gallagher again asking for an investigation. Filed. From R.G. Mackay and S.J. Emanuels reporting that they had taken the City census and found the population to be 18,260 and asking for $200.00 to cover a portion of the expenses. Referred to Finance Committee. From C.J. Mayne asking for a deeper drain on Princess Street. Referred to Board of Works. From Mrs Annie E. Webster asking for the free use of the Market Hall for a Charity Ball in aid of the Alexandra Hospital. Moved by Alderman Templeton Seconded by Alderman McDowell That the petition be granted. Carried. [Vol 4 page 536] From G.W. Thomas Market Clerk furnishing weekly report. From H.M. Williams et al asking for the grading etc of the lane in Block 7, 185. Referred to the Board of Works. From the City Engineer stating that he could not approve of the removal of the railing of the portions of Granville Street Bridge adjoining the draw without providing for some protection to the public in lieu of it. Referred to Board of Works. From Thos Byly et al asking for the opening up of 15th Av from Quebec St to Sophia St. Referred to Board of Works. From the Police reporting on the Electric Lights. Referred to F. W. & L. Committee. From J.J. Crane et al asking for the Sewering etc of the lane in Block 15, 196. Referred to Board of Works. From His Worship the Mayor asking the Council to donate a sum towards the Sir John A. Macdonald Memorial Fund. Moved by Alderman McDowell Seconded by Alderman C.L. Brown That the sum of $500.00 be donated by this Council in aid of the above fund. Moved in amendment by Alderman Scoullar Seconded by Alderman Brighouse That the question be referred to the Committee having the matter in hand. Carried. From His Worship the Mayor advising [Vol 4 page 537] that the City Scavengering be done by the City instead of by contract. Referred to the Board of Health. From D.M. Eberts stating that his company were quite willing to be bound

All correspondence between the City, the Dominion Government and the C.P.R. regarding the leper cases to be published. City Market hall rented for a Temperance lecture for the sum of $10. City Hall to be re-insured for $5,000 over 3 years at a premium of $400. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Martha Hazevoet and sponsored by Shirley Barnett original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 558-564 Vancouver, November 9, 1891 Vol. 4, pg. 558 The Council met on Monday, November 9, 1891. Present: His Worship the Mayor and Aldermen Carrall, Brighouse, Scoullar Hobson, Templeton, Wm. Brown and McDowell. The minutes of last meeting were read and adopted. The following communications were received and read: From H. Abbott, notifying the Council to remove the lepers from the shack where they are now confined. Referred to Board of Health From B.T. Rogers, Manager of the Sugar Refinery, asking for a return of all monies paid for water since August 1, 1891. From Dr. Brydone-Jack and J.A. Shearet, asking for the Market Hall for a Temperance lecture on the 13th inst. for a fee of $10.00. Moved by Alderman Templeton Seconded by Alderman McDowell That the prayer of the petitioners be granted. Carried From E.V. Chambers asking for a sidewalk on 7th Avenue from Block 100 to Block 97. Referred to Board of Works From Geo. Palloy asking that the sidewalk be widened on Gore Avenue. Referred to Board of Works From the Market Clerk furnishing weekly report. Filed Vol. 4, pg. 559 From the Chief of Police reporting on the electric lights. Filed From L. McLean et al asking for the opening of 8th Avenue one block west of Centre Street. Referred to Board of Works From J.A. Fulton, Secretary of the Trades and Labour Council, asking the Council the push the settlement of the leper question. Referred to Health Committee From Smith and Kidd asking for permission to cut wood on the streets and lanes. Referred to Police Committee From J. Duff Stuart asking for the Market Hall for a free lecture on Saturday evening. Moved by Alderman Brown Seconded by Alderman Templeton That the Hall be granted for the sum of $10.00. Carried From the St. Andrews Society asking the Market Hall for the 30th inst. Referred to Market Committee The following reports were received and read: FINANCE The Finance Committee met on Friday November 6th, 1891. Present: Aldermen Brown, Hobson, Carrall, and Scoullar A communication was received from Dr. Bredemeyer offering his mineral collection to the City for a stated sum. The City Solicitor advised that the City had not the power under the Charter to expend money for such purpose. Vol. 4, pg. 560 It was recommended: 1) That the following accounts be paid: Telephone Co. $ 22.80 C.P. Telegraph Co. 8.35 A. St. G. Hamersley, Law Costs 75.00 2) That the City Hall be reinsured in the Companies represented by Mr. H.S. Ceperley for 3 years for

Vancouver’s share of the cost of the Darcy Island leprosy quarantine will be 2/7, Victoria’s will be 5/7. W.J. Hogg wrote to request that the Sunday Closing By-Law be enforced. D.J. McLean awarded contract for supplying waterproof overcoats for the police force at a cost of $9.00 each. License Inspector authorized to purchase dog tags for next year’s use. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Margaret Sutherland and sponsored by Shirley Barnett original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 566-573 [Vol 4 page 566] Vancouver Nov 16th 1891 The Council met on Monday November 16th 1891 Present His Worship the Mayor and Aldermen Carroll, Scoullar, Godfrey, Hobson, Wm Brown, McDowell, C.L. Brown and Doering. The Minutes of last meetings were read and adopted. The following communications were received and read:- From Rand Bros. drawing attention to the condition of the drain in front of the Hotel Metropole. Referred to the Board of Works. From J.L. Franklin, Secretary to the City Band asking that the Council arrange re Bank practises in basement of the Market building. Referred to Market Committee From Dr. Bredemeyer asking the City to purchase his mineral collection. Referred to the Finance Committee. From the Market Clerk furnishing weekly report. Filed From Drs. Bell-Irving and Thomas reporting on the Lepers. Referred to Health Committee From W.J. Hogg asking that the Sunday Closing By-Law be enforced. Referred to Police Committee From Andrew Engle claiming $500 for coming to Vancouver on the strength of a telegram re crematory. Referred to Crematory Committee [Volume 4 page 567] From the Chief of Police reporting on the electric lights. Filed From R.B. Taylor et al asking for a 4 ft sidewalk on 11th Av. Referred to Board of Works. From J. Gosse et al asking for a sidewalk on Lorne Street. Referred to Board of Works. From A.H.B. McGowan, asking for the grant to the reading room to be paid over. Referred to Finance Committee From H. Abbott stating that he was unable to attend the meeting re lepers. Filed. From C. D. Rand Secretary to Gas Co withdrawing from sale the Gas Works. Referred to committee having matter in hand. The following Reports were received and read. Finance The Finance Committee met on Friday November 13th 1891. Present Aldermen Scoullar, Brown and Hobson. It was recommended:- 1. That the City Treasurer be authorized to deposit a cheque for $50 with the Customs House as a guarantee for the payment of the duty on the jaws of the rock crusher. 2. That the following accounts be paid:- John McDowell Expenses to Victoria $24.00 A.W. Scoullar “ 24.00 sgd Wm Brown, Chairman Moved by Alderman Godfrey Seconded by Alderman Doering That the Report be adopted. Carried [Volume 4 page 568] The Police Committee met on Tuesday November 10th 1891. Present Aldermen Hobson (in the Chair) Carroll, Scoullar and C.L. Brown. It was recommended:- 1. That D. J. McLean be awarded the contract for supplying the

A. Williams declined appointment as Police Magistrate with restrictions. $500 was set aside for the Free Library for the purchase of books only. Market Committee empowered to find out what it will cost to deaden sounds from the basement of the Market Hall. Evans Coleman and Evans to supply to the city garbage-burning facility one scow load of coal at $2.20 per ton delivered. Duncan McRae hired to build a 12' x 16' shelter for lepers on Darcy Island. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Bronwen Cripps and sponsored by Shirley Barnett City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 576-583credite Vancouver November 23rd, 1891 The Council met on Monday November 23rd, 1891. Present: Aldermen Carroll, Brighouse, Godfrey, Scoullar, Hobson, Templeton, Wm. Brown, McDowell and C.L. Brown. Moved by Alderman Godfrey Seconded by Alderman Templeton That C.L. Brown be approved Chairman Carried The minutes of the last meeting were read and adopted The following communications were received and read: From A. Williams refusing the position of Police Magistrate under the restrictions. Moved by Alderman Wm. Brown Seconded by “ Scoullar That the communications be referred to the Police Committee and that Mr. Williams be invited to be present. Moved in amendment by Alder (sic) McDowell Seconded by Alderman Godfrey That the communication be laid on the table to be taken up later in the evening. Amendment Carried. From the Chief of Police reporting on the electric lights. Filed From the Market Clerk furnishing weekly report. Filed From W. E. Graveley notifying the Council that the Insurance on Fire Hall No. 1 would expire on November 29th and asking for a renewal. Finances From W. F. Salsbury stating that he would undertake to carry out the wishes of the Council re auditing the Water Works Co’s books Filed From the City Solicitor stating the assignment for the Eagle Crematory Co. was in order but required the CO’s seal. Filed From J. A. Fulton Secretary of the Trades and Labor Council asking the Council to get the permission of the Dominion Government to erect bathing houses on English Bay Beach. Referred to Board of Works From Wm. L. Magee for Minister of Marine acknowledging the receipt of a communication from the City Clerk re the control by the City over the ends of Street. Police From C. C. Morrell on behalf of the Standard Oil Co asking for permission to erect a brick building on the C.P.R. reserve near Carl Av. for storing oil. Referred to F. W. & L. Committee From H. Mutrie at al on behalf of the Y.M.C.A. asking for the Market Hall for Dec. 1st for $10.00. Moved by Alderman Wm. Brown Seconded by “ Templeton That the Market Hall be granted to the Y.M.C.A. on the evening of Dec. 1st, 1891 for the sum of $10.00. Carried From Trueman and Caple asking for a grant in consideration of their growing lectures on British Columbia in England. Referred to Finance Committee From the City

A six foot sidewalk to be put on 7th Avenue to the Baptist Church, with stumps and roots “which may be obstructions” to be removed. The new Crematory (garbage burning) facility to be insured for $3,000. The City Clerk to have a sufficient number of ballot boxes for election purposes, said boxes to be made of galvanized iron. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Donna Kynaston and sponsored by Shirley Barnett original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 592-597 [Vol 4 page 592] Vancouver December 7th 1891 The Council met on Monday December 7th 1891. Present: Aldermen Carroll, Brighouse, Scoullar, Templeton, Hobson, Wm Brown, McDowell and C.L. Brown. Moved by Alderman Templeton Seconded by Alderman McDowell That Alderman Scoullar be appointed Chairman. Carried. The minutes of last meeting were read and adopted. The following communications were received and read: From Mayor Oppenheimer requesting the Council to order pipes for the extension of the water works system. Referred to Water Works Committee. From the Market Clerk reporting on the market receipts. Filed. From John McAllister drawing the attention of the Council to the manner in which F.K. Winch was carrying out his contract for the construction of the hose cart. Moved by Alderman Templeton Seconded by Alderman Wm Brown That John McAllister be invited to attend the next meeting of the Fire Water and Light Committee to be held at the City Hall on Wednesday the 9th day of December 1891 re his communication to Council. Carried. From James Nelson drawing the attention of the Council to the filthy condition of the [Vol 4 page 593] lane in Block 87, District Lot 196. Referred to the Board of Works. From E.C. Coldwell drawing attention to the non-completion of the order for the erection of electric lights on Keefer and Harris Streets. Referred to Board of F.W. & L. From J.T. Brown & Sons requesting that Howe St at the corner of Pender St be repaired. Referred to Board of Works. From the City Auditor submitting report of the receipts and expenditures for August. Referred to Finance Committee. From Andrew Engle drawing attention to the necessity of keeping competent men at the Crematory. Referred to Health Committee. From G.A. Jordan accepting the position of Police Magistrate. Filed. From the Chief of Police reporting on the Electric Lights. Filed. From G.W. Townsend asking for a street crossing on Westminster Road near M.J. Henry’s gardens. Referred to Board of Works. The following reports were received and read: Finance The Finance Committee met on Friday December 4th 1891. Present: Aldermen Brown, Scoullar, Hobson and Carroll. [Vol 4 page 594] It was recommended: 1. That the following accounts be paid: S.J. Tilley & Son, Stationery $52.40 2. That the City Solicitor be requested to return the cheque held by him for the purchase of portions of lots on Powell Street and that said cheque be cancelled. 3. That the City Clerk be instructed to have made a

Several by-laws were completed: Vagrancy, Bread, Guns etc., Pound, Market, Liquor, Fire Limit & Trades License. Use of the Market Hall was granted for the 26th of December to hold a concert in aid of the Alexandra Hospital. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Anonymous and sponsored by Shirley Barnett original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 page 600 only [Vol. 4, pg. 600] Vancouver December 11th, 1891 An adjourned meeting of the Council was held on Friday December 11th 1891. Present Aldermen Brighouse, Carroll, Scoullar, Templeton, Hobson, Wm Brown and Doering. Moved by Alderman Templeton Seconded by Alderman Scoullar That Alderman Brown we appointed Chairman. Carried. A Communication was received from J. A. Fulton Secy of the Trades and Labor Council asking for the Market Hall for the 26th inst to hold a concert in aid of the Alexandra Hospital Moved by Alderman Brighouse Seconded by “ Templeton That the hall be granted for this occasion. Carried Moved by Alderman Templeton Seconded by “ Hobson That the Rules be suspended and the following By-Laws read a first time, viz Vagrancy, Bread, Guns etc. Pound, Market, Liquor, Fire Limit, Trades License Alderman Hobson was appointed Chairman. These By-Laws were reported Completed with amendments. The Council then adjourned. D. Oppenheimer, Mayor Thos. F. McGuigan City Clerk

Special Meeting to review purchase of the Vancouver Electric Light and Street Railway Co. and to revise the Liquor License By-Law. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Anonymous and sponsored by Shirley Barnett original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 611-612 [Vol. 4, pg. 611] Vancouver December 16th, 1891 The Council met on Wednesday December 16th 1891. Present. His Worship the Mayor and Aldermen Carroll, Brighouse, Scoullar, Hobson, Wm Brown, McDowell, Doering and C.L. Brown. Moved by Alderman McDowell Seconded by “ Doering That the Council go into Committee of the Whole for the consideration of the proposition of the Electric Light Co. Carried Alderman Scoullar was appointed Chairman. A communication was read from J. W. Horne Esq. President of the Co. After due consideration it was moved by Alderman McDowell Seconded by Alderman C.L. Brown That the City accept the offer of the Company in accordance with the Company’s offer of the 15th inst for the purchase of their stock, and the securing of their debentures on the following basis:- For paid up Stock $162,000 “ Bonds 300,000 “ Other expenses etc. not to exceed 15,000 and a sum not to exceed $5,000 for the extension of the arc lights etc; and that a By-Law be introduced at the next meeting of Council covering the above agreement. Carried The Council then rose when it was moved by Alderman McDowell seconded by Alderman Templeton. That the motion passed in Committee of the Whole be sanctioned by Council. Carried The Council went into Committee of the Whole for the consideration of the liquor license [Volume 4 page 612] By-Law with Alderman McDowell in the Chair. The By-Law was read over clause by clause and reported as complete with amendments. The Council then adjourned. D. Oppenheimer Mayor Thos. F. McGuigan City Clerk

Final meeting of the Council of 1891 Fire Chief allowed to order caps for the whole department from New York, as “they are not manufactured in this city”. A Trades License By-Law was put through at the last moment. However, a motion to conclude the By-Law for the purchase of the Vancouver Street Railway & Electric Light Co by the City was lost. This transcript was made in 2016 by Transcribimus volunteer Anonymous and sponsored by Shirley Barnett original handwritten minutes here City of Vancouver Archives Series 23-A Volume 4 pages 619-625 [Vol. 4 page 619] The Council met on Monday December 28th 1891. Present: His Worship the Mayor and Aldermen Carroll, Brighouse, Scoullar, Templeton, Hobson, McDowell, Wm Brown and C.L. Brown. The Minutes of last meeting were read and adopted. The following communications were received and read:- From the Market Clerk reporting on the receipts. Filed. From the Pound Keeper submitting monthly Report. Filed. From the Chief of Police reporting on the Electric Lights. Filed. From John Brown et al asking for a sidewalk on Sophia Street & 14th Av. Referred to Board of Works. From Hanson Bros. notifying the Council that the Debentures has been forwarded. Filed. From Wm Smith, Department of Marine Ottawa, acknowledging receipt of resolution re bathing houses. Filed. From John Callister, asking for the refund of $10.00 put up by him on Sidewalk. Referred to Board of Works. From the City Solicitor stating that proper notice had not been given for the introduction of the St. Ry By-Law. Filed. [Volume 4 page 620] The following communications were received and read:- Finance Report The Finance Committee met on Monday December 28th 1891. Present Aldermen Brown, Hobson and Scoullar. It was recommended:- 1. That the following accounts be paid:- A.O. Leask Duty on Jaws $33.50 Van Free Reading Room Balance of Grant 375.00 Robertson & Hackett Map Rolls 1.80 McLennan & McFeely Box 2.00 Geo Bishop Debentures 451.10 C.P. Telegraph Co. 4.88 do do 18.48 Dominion Express Co. 15.85 S.T. Tilley & Son Stationery 8.75 2. That the communications from Godfrey & Co and Abray & Haywood re the damages to goods be referred to City Solicitor. 3. That the communication from the Secy of the School Board be laid over. sgd Wm Brown Chairman Moved by Alderman Brighouse Seconded by “ Carroll That the Report be adopted. Carried. Board of Works The Board of Works met on Thursday December 24th 1891. Present Aldermen Wm Brown, Brighouse and Templeton. It was recommended:- [Volume 4 page 621] 1. That the City Engineer be instructed to have a crossing put down at the intersection of Haro and Jervis Streets. 2. That the City Engineer be instructed to notify the Street Railway Co. to remove the obstructions on Hastings Street near Carrall at once otherwise the same will be removed at their expense. 3. That no more work be let this year and that the application for opening the lane in Block 101.541 be laid over for the new